Why Cheap Roofing Companies Can Cost You More in Sarasota

You’re looking to install a new roof and hoping to pay as little as possible. But here’s the truth: going with cheap roofing companies often backfires — big time.

Sure, the low price might seem appealing up front, but cutting corners can lead to poor craftsmanship, hidden costs, and expensive repairs. Let’s break down why “cheap” doesn’t always mean “good” when it comes to roofing in Sarasota.

The Dangers of Hiring Cheap Roofing Companies

1. Lack of Experience

Many low-cost roofing contractors are new or underqualified. They may be offering low bids to attract clients due to their lack of experience. But that inexperience can translate into faulty installations and major issues down the line.

Roofing a handful of homes is not the same as roofing hundreds. Hiring an inexperienced contractor puts you at risk — not just for poor workmanship but also for costly damage.

2. Dishonest Business Practices

Cheap roofing companies often rely on shortcuts to save time and money. This could mean using unskilled labor, skipping key steps in the process, or rushing through jobs.

Even worse? These contractors may vanish when problems arise, leaving you to hire a second company to fix the mess — doubling your overall costs.

3. Inferior Materials

Materials are a big part of your roof’s longevity. When you go with a budget roofing contractor, you’re more likely to get subpar products that wear out faster.

For instance, while quality asphalt shingles can last 25–30 years, the cheap ones might start deteriorating after 10–15 years, forcing premature replacement and additional expense.

What Is a Fair Price for Roofing Services?

In Sarasota, the average cost for a full asphalt shingle roof replacement ranges from $10,000–$20,000. This includes materials, labor, cleanup, and warranty-backed service.

If a roofing bid comes in way below this range, it’s a red flag. Always ask why their prices are so low and whether it reflects the quality of labor, licensing, materials, or insurance.

How to Identify a Reputable Roofing Contractor

✔️ Consider Experience

Look for contractors with at least 2–5 years of proven experience. This helps ensure they’ve handled a variety of roofing scenarios and have the skill to get your job done right the first time.

✔️ Verify Their License

In Florida, roofing contractors must be licensed. You can verify a roofer’s license using the Florida Department of Business & Professional Regulation search tool. Don’t hire a company that isn’t licensed — it’s not worth the risk.

✔️ Require Insurance

A legitimate roofing company should carry at least $1 million in both general liability and workers’ compensation insurance. Ask for a current Certificate of Insurance and make sure it lists your property as the insured party.

Without insurance, you could be on the hook for damages or injuries that occur during the project.

✔️ Ask About Warranties

Trustworthy companies stand by their work. Ask about labor and material warranties. Written warranties provide peace of mind and legal protection in case something goes wrong. Learn more from the FTC’s guide on warranties.

Why It Pays to Invest in Quality Roofing

Saving a few thousand dollars now by hiring cheap roofing companies may result in tens of thousands in repairs or replacements later. A leaky roof can lead to mold, insulation damage, and structural issues — all far costlier than a solid roof done right the first time.

Think of a roof as an investment in your home’s protection, energy efficiency, and value.

Looking for a Trusted Roofer in Sarasota?

If you’re ready to protect your home and avoid the headaches of hiring the wrong contractor, SonShine Roofing is here to help.

With over 38 years of experience serving Sarasota homeowners, we deliver high-quality roof replacements, repairs, and inspections — always with integrity, transparency, and craftsmanship.

Contact us today to schedule a consultation or inspection with one of our certified roofing professionals.